Catholic commentary on culture, media, and politics.

Friday, October 12, 2007

Jewish Power, Inc.

Does it go without saying that this kind of study, if conducted by certain Gentiles, would risk being construed as anti-Semitic?

2 Comments:

Anonymous Joanna Bratten said...

Crikey; it's Patrick Coffin! (I heard you'd turned serial blogger.) As both a Jew and an Opinionated Person I should have a view on this - I don't think it does go without saying, does it? Or has it got that bad in America? I'd comment on a couple of other posts but I think there might be a cyber-row of the most ferocious kind!

Glad to see you thinking and sharing the thoughts anyway!

11:09 AM

 
Blogger Patrick said...

Uh oh, looks like my favorite stalker has found me out! It's been a while, JB. I actually wasn't happy with the first post and made it right before reading your comment. I have no idea how one determine "bad," but we do read and hear a lot about the roots of anti-Semitism (which is a real problem in some parts among some people) and one of the alleged roots is the perpetual of stereotypes.

Well, I happen to believe that most stereotypes are true. Or at least they stem from solid and mostly reliably repeatable phenomena. Like the one about Jews having an out-of-proportion-to-their-numbers influence on American culture, media, etc. I have no problem with this being true. But saying it isn't true only means one is not paying attention. The Vanity Fair list is not a scientific study, but....

Per your temptation to comment on other posts, I'm not into ferocious rows, but knock yourself out.

Great to hear from you!

10:34 PM

 

Post a Comment

<< Home